Best Italian Restaurants in Baltimore

This beloved Baltimore Italian market and deli has earned its stellar reputation with over 2,000 glowing reviews, offering an authentic taste of old-world charm where you can stock up on imported Italian goods and enjoy freshly made sandwiches and prepared foods. Travelers rave about the quality and authenticity, making it a must-visit spot for anyone seeking genuine Italian flavors in Baltimore's Highlandtown neighborhood. Arrive early on weekends when the deli counter gets busy, and don't leave without grabbing some of their house-made specialties to take home.

Tagliata has earned its stellar reputation among Baltimore diners with over 1,700 glowing reviews, making it a reliable choice in the city's historic Fleet Street dining scene. The upscale pricing reflects a commitment to quality that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for its diverse menu offerings and inviting atmosphere. With such consistently high ratings, it's worth making a reservation ahead of time, especially for weekend dining when this popular spot fills up quickly.

Amicci's of Little Italy brings authentic neighborhood charm to Baltimore's historic Italian district, combining a lively bar atmosphere with classic Italian-American fare that has earned devoted fans among both locals and visitors. With over 1,600 glowing reviews and a stellar 4.5-star rating, travelers consistently praise the welcoming vibe and generous portions that make it a reliable choice in the heart of Little Italy. Snag a table during the early evening to enjoy the buzzing atmosphere before the dinner rush, and don't skip their bar offerings which are a highlight of the experience.

La Tavola has earned its stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with over a thousand glowing reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that offers something for every palate. The consistently high ratings reflect the restaurant's commitment to quality and service, making it a reliable choice whether you're celebrating a special occasion or seeking a satisfying meal in Baltimore's downtown. Given its popularity at the moderate price point, consider making a reservation ahead of time, especially for weekend dining.

Sotto Sopra brings authentic Italian elegance to Baltimore's Charles Street with refined dishes that have earned devoted fans among nearly a thousand diners who've given it top marks. Travelers consistently praise the sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere and consistently excellent food quality that justify the upscale pricing. For the best experience, make reservations ahead especially for weekend evenings, as this popular spot fills up quickly with both locals and visitors seeking memorable Italian cuisine.

Benny's is a beloved Baltimore institution where the bar meets neighborhood store vibe creates an authentic local hangout that has earned an impressive 4.8-star rating from over 800 visitors. Travelers consistently rave about the welcoming atmosphere and genuine character that makes this spot feel like a true slice of Charm City life rather than a typical tourist stop. Located in the heart of downtown on South High Street, it's the perfect place to experience Baltimore like a local, though be prepared for a lively crowd during peak hours.

This beloved Little Italy institution has earned its stellar reputation with over 850 diners praising its authentic neighborhood charm and consistently excellent Italian fare. Travelers appreciate the warm, old-school ambiance and generous portions that won't break the bank at moderate prices. Make a reservation for weekend evenings when this local favorite fills up quickly, and don't skip the classic pasta dishes that keep regulars coming back year after year.